Album Review :
Comrades - Lone / Grey

By in Reviews | 6 Comments

Comrades Lone Grey album cover

Label: Facedown Records
Release Date: October, 7th 2016


  1. In the Whisper, In the Gale
  2. Farewell
  3. Dark Tongues, Pt. II
  4. Empty Frame
  5. Synchronous
  6. Shepherd’s Hymn
  7. Underground Queen
  8. Brother(Less)
  9. Infinite Scale
  10. That One Day We May Be the Same

I have a long and rich history with the  band known as Comrades. With the trio being based in Virginia, I am but a stone’s throw away living in Pennsylvania myself. Due to our geographical locations, I have had the pleasure of seeing Comrades upwards of 20 times ranging from house shows in suburban neighborhoods to garages in the middle of the woods. Thinking over my relationship with the band and listening to their Facedown records debut, “Lone / Grey”, I am overcome with happiness and pride for the band I’ve watched tirelessly grind all of 8 years.

The first thing that jumps to the forefront when listening to “Lone / Grey” in contrast to any other of Comrades efforts is the focus on vocals. In the past, the band has often pushed any vocals way into the back of the mix; opting to not even use microphones while playing live. However, on this lush and powerful album, Lara and Ben’s vocal are front and center.

The dichotomy of dueling vocals allows for the harsh screams to contrast wonderfully against the beautifully crooned female vocals. Lead single of the album, Dark Tongues, Pt. II finds the band in full swing, displaying both sides of the vocal coin, while ever talented guitarist Joe McElroy toes the line between chunky aggressive riffs and delicately picked atmosphere. Fans of Beloved will find themselves picking their jaws off the floor during the final minute of the single as drummer, Ben Trussell channels his inner Joe Musten with blistering drum hits and throaty bellowing.

The real highlight of the album comes in the form of tracks 5 and 6, where Synchronous bleeds seamlessly into Shepherd’s Hymn. Starting off with the instrumental Synchronous, subtle electronics weave in and out between a steady drum beat and soft guitar picking before flowing into the breathy male vocals on Shepherd’s Hymn. Unlike the majority of the male vocals on the album, these start out clean at the forefront of a lush and breathtaking background of instrumentation before turning on a dime and adding grit back into the mix. All the aforementioned comes before Lara sings the closest thing to a chorus on the album as she hopefully croons,

“Bring me your anguish, I am the beam / The house of comfort and well kept dreams. Bring loss and bring me your care / I will restore and I will repair. Bring me your lonely nights of fear / Safety I am, I’ll always be near. Bring me your condemnation’s words / I’ll drown them in my love unearned”.

Tracks In the Whisper, In the Gale, Farewell, and Brother(Less) all go hand in hand; each showcasing the trickery the trio are capable of with frequently twisting and turning the listener’s attention with frantic fretboard finesse and guttural howls one moment while the next flexing their closed snare grooves backing delicate female vocals. These tracks are Comrades at their finest, feeling comfortable and familiar without letting things ever get stale.

That One Day We May Be the Same is a powerful closing track to this gem of an album. Only about 2:40 of the 6:09 duration of the track have vocals in them, trading back and forth between harsh and light vocals. However, the remaining 3:30 of the song are what truly shines. The instrumental section is not only beautiful as an outro of sorts, allowing the listener to digest the musical journey of “Lone / Grey”, but for a long time fan like myself, it allows a trip down memory lane. Over the remaining minutes of the track, I can not help but reminisce about all my times seeing the trio perform and even thinking back on their instrumental only phase as a band. Feelings and moments like that are to be cherished and something that not any album can bring you.

The only real drawback to the album is some of the predictability in the music, specifically early on in the record. With tracks like In the Whisper, In the Gale and Farewell, I felt as though I could predict when a vocal trade off was going to happen or when a tapping part was about to come in. While nonetheless impressive, I feel as though the group could benefit from having some songs that were all singing or all screaming in their arsenal just to mix things up.

A testament that hard work pays off, Comrades have created an album that transcends genres and stereotypes with “Lone / Grey”. This band is joy to follow and I implore you to check out some of their best work to date.

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mark K
Mark K
November 27, 2016 6:18 pm

I really enjoyed Safekeeper and when I first got this I was disappointed in the lack of “adventure” but man did this take hold a few days later. Frankly I am stunned by this release. It hits right where My Epic “Yet” and Attalus “Into The Sea” mixing aggression with striking beauty and space. Musically it’s better than both of those, lyrically it touches greatness. This is the biggest surprise of my year and bar none the best album I’ve heard perhaps in years. Lara’s vocals and her melodies along with clean breaks make this one incredible album!

Chris S
Chris S
April 20, 2017 7:10 am
Reply to  Mark K

Completely agree!

Chris S
Chris S
April 20, 2017 7:12 am

So I’m really late to this release, but wow! What an album! Diggin it.

December 1, 2016 10:11 pm

I was pretty intrigued by this, as something coming from Facedown. Finally, something to complement My Epic a little! I liked the album upon getting it, but there were two things that disappointed a bit: 1. After reading up on them and finding out how they are more an instrumental band, having nothing that actually WAS an instrumental seemed strange. Expecting something, based on previous work, but getting something that doesn’t meet those expectations, isn’t necessarily bad when all 3 of them are capable vocalists. 2. Lara’s singing is weird in this. Her voice isn’t bad, I don’t mean that.… Read more »

November 28, 2016 10:05 am

I agree with this review pretty much all the way. It’s a great mix that sets itself away from other bands yet in some ways a bit predictable.
I’d say my biggest complaint is, as angelic and graceful as Lara’s voice is, the lack of emotion or passion in her voice. But still a good album

BenjiKunz (formerly Lucas)
November 26, 2016 10:47 am

Great review. I really agree with that drawback, it’s the one thing I noticed myself. I was hoping for a moment that would really go all soft or all harsh and it didn’t happen. But as a whole, this is easily one of my favorite heavy releases of the year. I’ve never heard that combo of vocals before and the fact that they pull it off so well is incredible.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x